Home › Guides › Workers comp psychology claim disputed NSW

Workers Comp Psychology Claim Rejected or Disputed in NSW: Your Options

Getting a letter saying your workers compensation psychology claim has been disputed or rejected is stressful. It can feel like the system is working against you at a time when you are already dealing with a psychological injury. The first thing to know is that a rejection is not final. Under NSW law, you have formal review rights, and many psychological injury claim disputes are resolved in the worker's favour.

This guide explains why psychological injury claims are disputed more often than physical injury claims, what your review options are, and how to keep your psychology treatment going while a dispute is underway.

Why Psychological Injury Claims Are Disputed More Often

It is worth understanding why disputes happen before addressing how to respond to one. Psychological injury claims face additional hurdles compared to physical injury claims for several reasons:

Section 11A: The "Reasonable Management Action" Exclusion

Section 11A of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) states that an insurer or employer can exclude liability for psychological injury if the injury was the result of "reasonable management action taken in a reasonable manner." This includes actions such as:

• Performance management and counselling
• Demotion, transfer, or change in role
• Redundancy or retrenchment
• Disciplinary action
• Refusal of leave requests or promotions

This exclusion is complex and is frequently invoked. The important words are "reasonable manner" — management action that was unreasonable in how it was carried out may not qualify for the exclusion even if the action itself was permitted. The distinction has been tested extensively in the Personal Injury Commission and courts.

Causation: Proving the Workplace Was the Main Cause

Under NSW workers compensation law, a psychological injury must be "caused, contributed to, or aggravated by employment" and employment must be the "main contributing factor." For physical injuries, causation (a fall, a repetitive strain) is often more straightforward. For psychological injuries, establishing that the workplace — rather than personal circumstances — was the main contributing factor requires more detailed medical evidence.

Insufficient Documentation at the Claim Stage

Many disputes arise not because the injury did not occur, but because the initial documentation was insufficient. GP certificates that describe symptoms without connecting them to specific workplace events, or that do not address the contributing-factor test, give insurers grounds to dispute. This can often be resolved by obtaining supplementary medical evidence.

Your Three Review Options

If your claim has been disputed or rejected, work through these steps in order. Each step is free and each can resolve the matter without going to the next level.

Continuing Psychology While Your Claim Is Disputed

One practical concern when a claim is disputed is whether you can continue receiving psychological support. There are two pathways to consider:

Provisional Liability Period

When you first lodge a claim, the insurer is required to make a provisional liability decision within 7 days. During the provisional liability period, the insurer must generally fund reasonable and necessary initial treatment — even while investigating the claim. This means you may be able to start psychology and have the first session or sessions covered before liability is formally decided.

If the insurer then disputes liability, the provisional liability funding typically ends. Keep records of any sessions attended during this period; if the dispute is ultimately resolved in your favour, costs from the provisional period may be recoverable.

Medicare as a Parallel Pathway

While your workers compensation claim is being disputed, you can access psychology through Medicare using a separate pathway:

• See your GP and request a Mental Health Treatment Plan (MHTP)
• This allows up to 10 individual psychology sessions per calendar year with a Medicare rebate
• As of 1 July 2025: $145.25 rebate per session with a clinical psychologist; $98.95 rebate per session with a registered psychologist
• Typical Sydney fees are $230 to $300 per session — you pay the gap out of pocket
• This pathway is entirely separate from your workers compensation claim and does not affect your dispute

Using Medicare while your claim is disputed keeps your psychological support continuous rather than waiting months for the dispute to resolve. If your claim is ultimately accepted, you may be able to switch back to workers compensation funding.

See the workers comp psychology cost guide for a comparison of SIRA rates versus Medicare rebates.

What Documents You Will Need

Having the right documentation strengthens your review at every stage:

• Original claim documents: Your certificate of capacity, the claim form, any correspondence from the insurer including the dispute or rejection letter
• Medical evidence: GP reports and any reports from your psychologist or psychiatrist that connect your diagnosis to workplace factors. Reports should specifically address the "main contributing factor" test where possible
• Workplace records: Contemporaneous records of incidents, emails, performance reviews, or any documentation of the events contributing to your injury. These are particularly relevant if section 11A (management action) is invoked
• Witness statements: Statements from colleagues who can corroborate workplace events, if available
• Records of medical expenses: If you paid for any sessions out of pocket while the claim was being decided, keep receipts

Getting Legal Help

You do not need a lawyer for an internal review or SIRA merit review. However, if your dispute is complex, involves a section 11A defence, or has reached the PIC stage, legal advice is strongly recommended.

Workers compensation lawyers in NSW:

• Typically offer a free initial consultation
• Typically operate on a no-win-no-fee basis for workers compensation matters
• Can review your dispute and advise whether additional medical evidence is needed
• Can represent you at PIC proceedings

The icare Injury Help Hub (phone: 1800 737 822) can provide information and guidance on the dispute process without cost. You can also contact LawAccess NSW (1300 888 529) for free legal information about workers compensation disputes.

The Psychological Impact of a Disputed Claim

Having a claim disputed adds another layer of stress on top of an existing psychological injury. This is widely recognised in the workers compensation system — but it does not make it any easier to experience. If you are finding the dispute process significantly difficult, speaking with your GP about support options is worthwhile regardless of what is happening with your claim. Your GP can arrange Medicare-funded psychology sessions while the dispute is ongoing (see above), so there is not a gap in care while the process unfolds.

This guide provides general educational information about NSW workers compensation dispute processes. It is not legal, insurance, or clinical advice. Information is current as at June 2026; refer to SIRA NSW and Personal Injury Commission NSW for the most current guidance. Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) s.11A; Personal Injury Commission Act 2020 (NSW).